If you’ve got your heart set on a floor that looks like real wood, you might want to compare engineered wood flooring vs laminate flooring. Both options are durable and boast the grains, knots and colour variation of real oak. However, each floor has its differences when it comes to ease of installation, water-resistance, scratch-resistance and cost.
In this blog, we detail the pros and cons of engineered wood flooring and laminate flooring and what each delivers when it comes to durability, maintenance, room suitability and more. So, let’s dive in!
What’s The Difference Between Laminate and Engineered Wood Flooring?
When thinking about engineered wood flooring vs laminate there are a few key differences to consider.
Engineered wood flooring is constructed from either softwood, plywood or HDF (high-density fibreboard) which creates a strong, sturdy base. The base is then topped with a thin veneer of real oak. This multi-layered construction means engineered wood boasts all the beauty of solid wood but with a much lower price tag!
Engineered wood flooring is finished with either an oil or a lacquer. An oiled finish provides a beautiful, natural look but minimal water-resistance as it sinks into the wood. A lacquered finish creates a water-resistant barrier on the surface of the wood which provides a glossy sheen.
Laminate flooring is made from a base of HDF which ensures the floor is durable enough to withstand any knocks and bumps. The base is also given a high-performance backing layer to prevent the floor from warping.
Once the base is complete, a photographic layer is added on top to create the illusion of a wood or stone floor. The laminate is protected by a transparent, scratch-resistant and water-resistant coating.
With all the durability of a water-resistant floor and the aesthetic of wood or stone, laminate is a fantastic alternative to real oak or slate and costs a fraction of the price!
Pros and Cons of Laminate Flooring
There are lots of reasons to choose laminate flooring – it’s affordable, easy to clean and durable enough to handle daily life. But that doesn’t mean it’s the right choice for you. Read on for the pros and cons of laminate flooring.
Benefits of Laminate Flooring
- Affordability – Laminate is one of the most affordable floors available, making it ideal if you want a lovely new floor but you have a tight budget.
- Easy to install – Most laminate floors are fitted with a handy click-fit system, allowing you to simply ‘click’ the boards into place like a jigsaw.
- Easy to maintain – Laminate doesn’t need much maintenance to keep it looking clean and fresh. A quick sweep and a weekly mop will do the job!
- Durability – Laminate is extremely hardwearing, making it perfect if you’ve got kids or pets at home.
- Water-resistance – Laminate is water-resistant, so it’s ideal for areas like the kitchen or dining room, where spills are likely.
- Range of designs – Laminate is available in a variety of styles and colours, so you’ll find a floor to suit any decor.
- Looks like real wood or stone – Laminate is a brilliant alternative if you love the look of natural materials like oak or slate but your budget won’t stretch to the real thing.
- Underfloor heating compatible – Underfloor heating works wonderfully under laminate, so you’ll stay toasty, whatever the weather!
Disadvantages of Laminate Flooring
- Can’t sand and refinish – Unlike wood flooring, laminate can’t be sanded and refinished when signs of age appear. This means that when your floor starts to look worn, you’ll need to replace it.
- Thinner than other floors – Laminate flooring ranges from between 6-12mm thick which means it’s often thinner than other floors like solid and engineered wood.
- Shorter lifespan than other floors – As laminate can’t be refinished it may not last as long as a solid or engineered wood floor.
- Not a natural product – Unlike solid wood, laminate flooring is manmade, so it might not be ideal if your heart is set on natural materials.
Pros and Cons of Engineered Wood Flooring
Engineered Wood flooring boasts all the beauty and character of real oak, costs less than solid wood and lasts for decades. That said, it might not be the ideal choice for your home. Let’s look at the pros and cons of engineered wood flooring.
Benefits of Engineered Wood Flooring
- Affordability – Engineered wood has the same natural look and feel as solid wood but comes with a slightly lower price tag. This means it’s a great choice if you want a real wood floor but you’re working with a smaller budget.
- Durability – Engineered wood is extremely durable and unlike solid wood it can resist changes to moisture and humidity. This means you can use it for areas where solid wood isn’t ideal, like the kitchen, conservatory or summer house.
- Long lifespan – Engineered wood can be sanded and refinished when it starts showing signs of age. As a result, engineered wood lasts longer than LVT and laminate flooring, usually 30+ years.
- Natural materials – Unlike wood effect LVT and laminate flooring, engineered wood contains natural wood, making it ideal if you prefer real materials to man-made ones.
- Range of options – Engineered wood is available in a range of colours, from natural wood shades to white and grey. You can also choose from a variety of styles, so whether you love the look of straight plank, herringbone, chevron or versailles, you’ll find a gorgeous floor you’ll adore.
- Underfloor heating compatible – Unlike solid wood, engineered wood flooring can be fitted over underfloor heating, so you’ll never worry about cold feet again!
Disadvantages of Engineered Wood Flooring
- Not always water-resistant – Unlike LVT and laminate flooring, engineered wood isn’t always resistant to water. If you choose a lacquered finish, the lacquer will protect against splashes and spills. However, you won’t get the same water-resistance with an oiled engineered wood floor.
- Not scratch-resistant – Engineered wood isn’t as resistant to scratches as some LVT and laminate floors are, so it’s not always best if you have pets at home. But, if you’re sold on an engineered wood floor, a brushed floor is a great alternative, as the textured effect will disguise scratches. Be sure to opt for an oiled finish, as lacquer will highlight any scratches!
- Shorter lifespan than solid wood – Engineered wood can last for more than 30 years. However, solid wood has a much longer lifespan and can usually be sanded and refinished more times than engineered wood.
- Takes time to install – As long as you’ve done your research and prep, there’s no reason you can’t install your own engineered wood floor. But whether you’re DIY-ing it or you’ve hired a professional, it’s worth noting it will take longer to fit than laminate or LVT flooring.
- Not the cheapest option – While engineered wood flooring is more affordable than solid wood, it still costs a bit more than LVT and laminate flooring. If your renovation budget is tight, engineered wood might not be ideal.
Durability and Maintenance
If you’re weighing up engineered wood flooring versus laminate, you might be wondering how the two compare on durability. Here, we break down everything you need to know.
Laminate is extremely durable which makes it ideal for homes with kids and pets. Its water-resistant surface means a dropped sippy cup or your dog’s post-shower shake-off can be cleaned up quickly, leaving your floor good as new. Check out our guide to maintaining laminate flooring for our top tips!
Laminate is also scratch-resistant, so anything from a case of dog ‘zoomies’ to your little one’s toy car races won’t leave a lasting mark.
The one thing to keep in mind about laminate is that while it’s not easy to damage it, once any damage is done, you’ll need to replace the affected boards.
Engineered wood is hardwearing but doesn’t offer the scratch-resistance or water-resistance that laminate does, so it’s important to consider this if you have kids or four-legged friends.
If you want a wood floor but you know scratches will be inevitable, go for a brushed and oiled floor to make sure any marks are hidden by the texture of the brushed wood. If you’re sold on real wood but need protection from splashes and spills, a lacquered engineered wood floor is the one for you.
The good thing about choosing engineered wood flooring is that it can be sanded and refinished if any damage occurs, so you won’t have to replace any planks or worry about replacing your whole floor. But, before you try that, remember to read our guide to removing stains from engineered wood flooring!
Cost Comparison
Cost is another factor in the engineered wood flooring vs laminate comparison.
Laminate flooring costs less to make than wood and LVT, making it the most affordable flooring option on the market. Prices for our laminate floors start from just £12.99m². Laminate is also easier and quicker to install than engineered wood, which means you can fit it yourself and save on installation fees.
Engineered wood is more expensive to produce than laminate flooring, so naturally it costs a bit more. Our engineered wood floors start from £25.99m², although you might be able to snap one up for less in one of our sales! Keep in mind that fitting engineered wood can be time-consuming, so if you’re planning to hire a professional fitter, you’ll need to budget for labour costs too.
Suitability for Different Rooms
Being water-safe and scratch-resistant, laminate is suitable for all kinds of rooms, including areas where spills are likely and where temperatures and humidity fluctuate, such as your kitchen or conservatory. However, it’s not completely waterproof, so we don’t recommend installing it in bathrooms.
Engineered wood’s hardwearing nature makes it ideal for areas with lots of people coming and going, like living rooms and hallways. However, it’s not designed to cope with lots of moisture, so avoid moisture-prone areas like the bathroom. And remember, if you want to fit engineered wood in your dining room or kitchen, be sure to choose a lacquered finish to protect your floor from splashes and spills.
Which Is the Most Realistic?
When comparing engineered wood flooring vs laminate for authenticity, engineered wood comes out on top. The real oak layer boasts the unrivalled beauty of wood, giving your floor the look and feel of solid oak.
Laminate has come a long way since the 80s and no longer has a reputation for looking cheap or fake. Wood effect laminate does a great job of mimicking the patterns and colours of real oak, while embossing creates texture. That said, nothing can match the awe-inspiring beauty of a real wood floor.
Underfloor Heating Compatibility
If you’re wondering about underfloor heating in the engineered wood flooring vs laminate comparison, we have good news! Both engineered wood and laminate flooring can be used with underfloor heating.
If you’re choosing laminate flooring, you’ll need a thermal foam underlay with a fairly low TOG rating. The higher the TOG rating, the more insulation your underlay will have and while insulation is great for keeping heat in, if you’re using it with underfloor heating it needs to be thin enough for the heat to escape your floor!
Read our blog to find out more about using engineered wood flooring with underfloor heating.
Which Flooring Is Best for Pet Owners?
If you’ve got a furry friend or two at home you’ll be wondering how each floor stacks up in the engineered wood flooring versus laminate debate.
Spills, scratches and little accidents are inevitable with animals, especially puppies and kittens who aren’t fully toilet-trained! Laminate is not only scratch-safe and water-resistant, it’s quick and easy to clean too, making it ideal for pet owners. Laminate is also extremely affordable, so if your pet does manage to do some damage, replacing the affected boards won’t hit your bank balance hard.
Engineered wood doesn’t offer the same durability as laminate, but that doesn’t mean it’s out of the question for pet owners. If you’re worried about accidents and spills, we recommend choosing a lacquered floor. Lacquered wood is water-resistant and you’ll find it easier to clean than an oiled wood floor.
If your concern is scratches, opt for a brushed and oiled engineered wood floor. The brushed effect creates a textured look that’s perfect for hiding scratches. Just keep in mind that an oiled floor won’t be water-resistant, so you’ll need to act fast if there’s a spill!
Top tips for protecting your floor from pets:
- If choosing a floor that’s not scratch-resistant, use rugs or runners to protect your floor.
- Trim your pets’ claws regularly to prevent scratches.
- Put mats under food and water bowls to reduce the risk of stains when anything spills.
Which Is Better for You?
As you can see, when looking at engineered wood flooring versus laminate there are pros and cons to each option. What’s best for you will depend on your lifestyle, your household and your personal preference!
If you’re after an affordable floor that’s easy to clean and maintain and offers lots of durability, laminate flooring is the one for you.
If you’re not on a tight budget and want an authentic-looking wood floor that’s designed to last decades, engineered wood will be a great choice.
Whichever floor you choose, be sure to take advantage of our unlimited free samples. You can order as many as you like until you find your perfect match!
Get Social
Still not sure which floor to choose? Get in touch with our friendly flooring experts, they’re always happy to help.
Don’t forget to follow us on Instagram and TikTok for all the latest news, blog posts and handy tips and tricks. Tag us on Instagram #MyLuxuryFloor and mention us on TikTok @luxuryflooringfurnishing. We’d love to see how your new floor has turned out!
The post Laminate vs Engineered Wood Flooring: Comparison appeared first on Blog & Advice Centre – Luxury Flooring & Furnishings.
This post appeared first on https://www.luxuryflooringandfurnishings.co.uk